It’s been nearly three months since Season 34 of Dancing With the Stars concluded, and fans are anxiously waiting for scoop about the show’s future. Recently, there’s been buzz about a possible All-Star season, which would bring back past contestants for another shot at the Mirrorball Trophy.

It’s been 14 years since the one and only returnee installment (Season 15), so there’s a huge pool of stars to choose from if All-Stars makes a comeback. TV Insider caught up with DWTS pros Emma Slater and Alan Bersten, who admitted they “don’t know” if All-Stars is happening, but revealed who they’d want to work with again if it does.

Originally published on tvinsider.com, part of the BLOX Digital Content Exchange.